Confucius is the paradigm of philosophy of law of harmony, “benevolence” is the cornerstone of its paradigm, June, individual, family and country and the people of harmony is the paradigm of content, ceremony, German, and means of punishment is harmonious, and constructing harmonious Datong is the purpose of the world.
Confucian political philosophy has always been valued by the people, but such attention is not comprehensive enough, too dependent on its moral thought, its philosophy too neglected. Confucius emphasized virtue as soft means and no means to ignore the rule of law, a tougher, the rule of law as a means of iron is absolutely indispensable, but if only emphasize the rule of law as a tool, abandon the moral basis of the rule of law, it contains a lot of theoretical risk, eventually leading to failure of the ruling. This is proved by the history, shows remarkable insight in this matter of Confucius and prescient. Regardless of morality of Confucius, is also the rule of law, the ultimate aim is to achieve a harmonious, can say that harmony is the paradigm of the philosophy of Confucius, as originator of separation of Montesquieu says we should use the law to clarify the history, to clarify the legal history. As pointed out by the historical School of Savigny, method is the generation of national spirit and national embodiment of consciousness, he also noted that law arises from not only the national spirit and national awareness, development of the law cannot be separated from the same national spirit and national consciousness. You can see from the Chinese legal system, Confucianism or lay in the Confucian consciousness deeply in our national brand, regardless of the law from the past, is also from the present law, more or less found Confucian shadow. Chinese traditional philosophy is based on Confucian’s thought of philosophy of law as the backbone and Orthodox, and the basic features of Confucian philosophy is ethical method, culvert on the relationship between legal relations to ethics, code of ethics to captain and guide laws, ethical value in for the law of value, so is ethics as method of primitive, noumenon and value orientation of philosophy of law. And this is both a concept and idea of ethics or into entities and outside objects, including individuals, families, groups, and both national ethics. Its connotation in the principles of the rule, in the political system and State structure. And Confucius ‘ Confucianism as the first person to do sth, its harmonious Chinese nation as a paradigm of the philosophy of law, of course, the Visual sense of law or the spirit of the law.
First, the cornerstone of harmonious.
Confucius is the entire purpose of legal philosophy of harmony, and Jen is the basic starting point of his philosophy ontology. Its basic meaning, as Hegel’s absolute relationship between concept and system of philosophy of law. However, Hegel’s concept of absolute time and space is an abstract, and ren of Confucius is highlighting the profound meaning of people’s subjective consciousness, is the sublimation of human practical reason. Inheritance of Confucius in ancient peoples social democratic legacy and abstract translated into principles of benevolence, established in his own blood clan ethics based humanistic noumenon of philosophy of law. This view of legal philosophy ontology is to be established, it is the legal subject status clear grasp of the phenomenon in the world, and reflects the development of Chinese legal history from savage to a harmonious civilization process, reflect the value being seriously, people gradually improving the status of historical fact. It from one side of the overview of the legal system of Chinese ancient society, put forward rational arguments. Confucian benevolence ontology content: first define what kernel? in the study of Confucian thought of the most reliable publications is also a Confucian classic!
In the Analects, told ren more than 109 times. Benevolence, love can be seen as always with an overview on ren of Confucius, Fan Chi asked yan. Confucius lover (the Analects · Yan Yuan). Love is the true feelings of compassion, concern and caring for others. These emotions through the filial piety, fraternal love, loyalty, faithfulness, Prince Gong, wide, sensitivity, wisdom, temperature, Leung, frugality, let, loyalty and other good deeds and virtues. Visible, ren is the sum of all kinds of virtues, is the highest pursuit of life. Be benevolent, it is difficult. So Confucius is never easy to benevolent people, nor to the benevolent self.
Since love is the true feelings of love revealed to others, so this thought reflects on people’s emphasis and concern. Publication: stable burned child go, said: ‘ wounding ‘? do not ask the horse. (The Analects · fellow villager or townsman) Corral fire, Confucius was concerned people have hurt. Confucius also of inhuman slavery so objectionable, the instigator, no designation (the Mencius · on the Liang huiwang), vicious curses Terra-cotta, wooden figurines of immolation of man with Earth. Clay figurines, wood figurines immolation, is so hated, you can imagine his sympathetic attitude to people. Confucius thought of love also reflects a profound understanding of the human value. He set off from the real world, based on the world, focusing on personnel, emphasized the existence of and respect for people, think humans can only be resolved by the humans, never’s hope that the ghosts: child, force, chaotic, not blame God. (The Analects · in) Zi Lu asked about ghosts, Confucius said, ‘ not who, how to please a ghost ‘. (The Analects · Yung) Zi Lu asked to die, Confucius said: unknown how known dead. (The Analects · Yung) he also said: the people, religion, by staying away. (The Analects · Yung), Confucius is not atheist, did not deny the existence of ghosts.
But he is to leave the question open to ghosts, kept at a distance of attitude, its purpose is to pay attention to personnel, not ghosts. Indeed Confucius stressed people is the goal, France and Germany just means. The relationship between moral and law is a source and stream, how can the people of the purpose of the relationship and why the people of known means. Person is uppercase in the philosophy of Confucius, born of heaven, Earth, human, which is consistent and Kant’s ideas!!! People at all times must be seen as objective. [1] Confucius by said of try a case, my Judah people also, will also makes no litigation between (Analects · Yan Yuan under), indicates that he resolve try a case and for no Court of legal method and target pursuit; legal penal evil just means and non-purpose, thus most ideal of State is everyone can comply with statutes and from by its penalty; rule of law of importance never means was: criminal heavy, and method cool, and case more, and prisoners all, instead evil method in essentially and rule of law is opposition of, real of rule of law Dang established good method Shang. Only benevolent good guy, the wicked (the Analects · LY Nhan); If interested in kernel, no evil (the Analects · LY Nhan); Ji Kangzi stolen asked Yu Kongzi, Confucius’s answer was: If the child does not wish to, although tours do not steal!
(The Analects · Yan Yuan) of a language (Ji Kangzi) stolen (Ji Kangzi) corruption; contact after the first religion, not teaching and kill that claims of child abuse. A spirit of national culture, ethical concept, reasonable core legal principles are unchanged, the law embodied in the kernel as the core, justice principles are immutable human purpose. Based on Confucian benevolence to promote social development, social justice, courtesy, moral education, benefiting the State measures to reduce the occurrence and prevention of crime, so as to build a harmonious society.
Second, harmonious content.
(A) people with great harmony.
In the Confucian philosophy of harmony between the first demonstration of the people and in June, Confucius knows of the relationship with the monarch. Also recorded in the book of the Xunzi had put people in the basic position of Confucius replied: and Cumulus smell it, June, boats also; the common person, water, water, boat, water, overturn it. [2] later famous water boat, can also overturn it this aphorism is at the base of this. In fact requires the construction of harmonious society of Confucius philosophy, coordinated relationship with the monarch, and this coordination of thought is that people thought and relative of the monarch.
1. people thought.
Recorded in the Analects: people in the kernel, rather than fire. It pointed out that people were looking forward to fire and more benevolent than demand urgent. Weight: people, food, death and sacrifice. That is in the minds of Confucius, people living in the first place, the second largest food, people actually still severe performance. Available Disan、sidian had joined the one sentence summary: shenzhongzhuiyuan, de thick. Caution is the running of parents ‘ funeral, recovery of far is to do well in ancestor worship, still is the embodiment of the thought of people. Mencius ‘ for your later, State Second, June light of thought remains the inheritance and development of this idea, that idea makes the most essential points of Confucianism. Zi Gong Wenzheng. Confucius said, ‘ enough food. Foot soldiers. The letter. ‘ Zi Gong said: ‘ have no choice but to go in the three first? ‘ He ‘ to soldiers. ‘ Zi Gong said: ‘ have no choice but to go to where the two first? ‘ He ‘ to eat. Both die since ancient times, people have no letter does not state. ‘ (The Analects · Yan Yuan) food foot fresh representative enough, now, is to promote economic construction, foot soldiers, is to strengthen national defense construction; the letter is to win. In the view of Confucius, death is not terrible, the worst is to lose popular support, lose popular support for the monarch is no cure for the blaze. Visible are dead since ancient times, people have no letter does not state who the rule of the principles is most difficult, is also a Grand people deal with harmony in Confucianism most precious spiritual wealth.
2. a relative of the monarch.
Although Confucius advocates humanism, but never denied the monarch’s dominance is only of relative of the monarch. Way in the world, go on a punitive expedition from son of Rite and music; there’s no road, the rites and go on a punitive expedition from the nobility. Dukes, covers ten Greek Cypriots losing; since the doctor out, v-Greek losing; vassal state of practice, sanshixi losing. Way in the world, the Government should not at the doctor. Way in the world, the common person is not discussed. (The Analects · Ji Shi) there’s no road here refers to the social life of all the political and legal order was broken, the Central Government to local control, there is no way to implement the command, formed a local separatist rule of dictatorship, the reunification of the country under threat. Confucius advocated national unity, and unified under one monarch. In fact this assertion refers to Confucius ‘ idea of absolute monarchy, against democracy, but, according to the requirements of Confucius, to become a qualified monarch was almost perfect, it is very difficult. Kid shoes, daring with a mysterious male, dare to proclaim after huanghuang; guilty not of their sins. Robinson does not cover, Jane in the heart of Emperor. I shall bow guilty, no to Wanfang, Wanfang guilty, I shall bow in the crime. Give: a week, doer is rich, despite the week-parent than renren.
People have, to a person. (The Analects · Yao Yue) thus Confucius advocated absolute monarchy was established with the people on the basis of this, the monarch must represent the interests of the people, or is not qualified for the monarch, they cannot live in harmony with the people, people will be up to overthrow him, thought of this idea is revolutionary, pointed out that in the book: world revolution and the four seasons. Tang Wu revolution, instead, who meets with the days. [3] century of good human State, could also win remnant to kill (the Analects · zilu); child said that of the Shaoguan: the best of us, and do good; that of the weapons: US Customs, not completely good. (The Analects · eight of a dance Squad) Tang Wu revolution should be said that Confucius was fully confirmed, but it was through war and win, compared with the Yu Shun perfect exhaust for, although the United States and has not made good, this sentence shows that the goal orientation of Confucian philosophy. Later, strongly commended the Tang Wu revolution of Mencius. Confucius advocated partly of the monarch in recognition of June, Robinson, is relative equality between people, is on the right and obligation of harmonious, not bias, unlike in later development to extremely Grand feudal dictatorship to Robinson died, Robinson had to die for the monarch of the kind of absolute rights of possession to Cape Collinson, far from harmonious pattern.
(B) the individual, family, national harmony.
In the Analects, Confucius also elaborated on their personal, family, national philosophy of harmony, their family, society and country among the three groups.
First, in the family, mainly in the form the harmonious relationship between man and man parent Chee children filial piety. Child on parents to best of filial piety. When the parents live, children should stay home serve: Confucius said parents, not travelled far, travel following. (The Analects · LY Nhan) serve parents, to make every effort to: parents, exhausting their forces. (The Analects ·) treat one ‘ s parents with filial piety to parents, not only should also respect. Confucius said: the piety of this, is that, as a dog or a horse, can have rather than, why not? (The Analects · political) disrespect, and raising a dog or a horse there is no difference. Therefore, by gift; died, was buried with ceremony, sacrifice ceremony (the Analects · politics). On the relations between parents and children, Confucius did not unilaterally request children fulfil his obligations claims on parents!!! John Keats. He Meng Wubo asked piety. Zi: its parents (child) disease worries. This remark while speaking or for reasons of piety, but on the other side shows, parents should love his son and General, lest their son’s illness is often thought that worry. Confucius says father parent, Kogo is the obligation of the parent to parent, that is, obligations of a child must do, and father look like a parent, loving care for the child, can justly demand zixiao. In addition, treat one ‘ s parents with filial piety to parents think their children should be at heart of Confucius sincerely respect parents, not distinguish non-, blind faith ignorance of parents of filial piety. Blind parents, is not a filial piety. Amiable piety is a different form of love, therefore, is a loving relationship between parents and children, rights and obligations between them is mutual. Later feudal parent for the child outline of principles of the code, all the powers vested in the parents, maintain absolute fatherhood, children only obligations, no right, apparently on Confucius thought of amendments. However, filial and fraternal love, and its known (the Analects ·), filial and fraternal love, honor your father, respect their elders, is the root of benevolence. This shows in the coordination of family rights and obligations between parents and children relations, value tends to fatherhood.
Second, in the State, mainly in the form the harmonious relationship between man and man-June envoys to, Robinson something Grand to loyalty (the Analects · eight a dance Squad). State is actually a family of amplification. Monarch equivalent to the parent, subjects correspond to our children. Therefore, move between filial piety and loyalty of Confucius, asked officials to June to cheating on King to shun. He reverses the pecking order in the spring and autumn era, ignoring the reality of monarchs and the whip, proper way in the world, go on a punitive expedition from son of Rite and music; there’s no road, the rites and go on a punitive expedition from the nobility (the Analects · Ji Shi). [World papers] insecure sovereign status, power down, chizhiwei moral chaos. He strongly advocated the taking, determine 君君, Robinson Robinson birthright of hierarchy, and is seen as a treatment of the priority tasks of the State: name not being the midst does not shun the thing, and not a rite be out of fashion, rites and be out of fashion in the penalty does not, penalties not then be at a loss as to what to do. (The Analects · zilu) in order to maintain the position of monarch, asked officials to June to dedicated, loyal: you, due to its body. (The Analects ·) things you do. (The Analects · eight a dance Squad, Robinson something Grand to loyalty. However, Confucius also had claims on June. June mainly to treat officials do their King’s road. June envoys to ceremony, Robinson something Grand to loyalty only to treat officials showed the monarch, his party allegiance monarch. He opposed the subject line does not distinguish the good and evil, whether the monarch’s stubborn loyalty. Subject to the monarch not to go out of one ‘ s way to Cury favour, should dare to advise frankly: not to be bullied, and offense. (The Analects · q) monarch if the shield a shortcoming or fault refused advice, subject would rather left him to go: take road King, is not available. (The Analects · q) monarch, wise, and will be an official; monarch, stupid non-road, to be an official shameful: Bang Eng, Valley, bang no road, Valley, and shame. (The Analects · asked), between the Emperor and harmony is in the form of love. Although this is a harmonious focuses on monarchical, but is restricted to the monarchical power. June Robinson outline is actually later generations on Confucius thought of amendments.
Thirdly, relations between people and between people in society is what you dislike yourself yourself (the Analects · of the Duke Ling of Wei). Clans and groups of countries in the relationship between man and man is primarily based on blood ties, political formation of specific identity relationship. In addition to these specific identity relationship is based on a common property of society and the formation of the relationship between man and man. Relationship between man and man are universal social groups, clans and groups in the country has the particularity of the relationship between man and man. So Confucius is how to construct the universal significance of the relationship between man and man is it? He said: the servant of the benevolent, wishes to State, and has to transmit. To collect close to Pi, Yan also. (The Analects · of the Duke Ling of Wei) they want to stand, but also to make others stand; want to satisfy their own requirements, the requirements are met to make others also, so people harmonious. Near PI method is to collect, that is, put yourself in, care from, push and the people for the sake of others. This method get on with people, Confucius also call it cheating. This is a positive way to live in harmony with people. Confucius said: do as you would be, yourself. Is that they do not like something, don’t impose on others. And human harmony, Confucius called it. Than it’s own desire State who own desire for loyalty with up to, and live in harmony with people in some negative way, but relatively easy to do. When Zi Gong asked Confucius: a word that could be life-line? (The Analects · of the Duke Ling of Wei) Confucius Quiz: their subject! What you dislike yourself, yourself. (The Analects · of the Duke Ling of Wei) loyalty seen as running through his own ideology of Confucius and the fundamental criteria of interest. The so-called way of the master, loyalty and truth (the Analects · LY Nhan). Zhong Road fully reflected the will of the people and mutual understanding and mutual respect between people. Compared to June, more equality between father and son sex, more in harmony.
Three, harmony means.
Confucius in constructing a harmonious society, mainly uses the following three methods: courtesy, morals, criminal.
(A).
Ceremony is a formation in Western Zhou dynasty, the complete set of institutions, etiquette and customs, the basic content of which is the blood as a link, junjun, Robinson Robinson, parent, father, Kogo as the core of patriarchal hierarchy. The first area to about. Confucius say: self-restraint and return to ritual as ren. (The Analects · Yan Yuan) visible, complex ritual as a means of self-denial. The so-called: See No Evil, no evil hear no evil, no evil. (The Analects · Yan Yuan) If you are able to discipline themselves, they can do without fault, never errors of conduct: the gentleman learned to text about by gift, husband to Bank of the River. (The Analects · LY Nhan) herself, naturally forming knowledge Shou character, self-care in the conduct of life, so that it will not go wrong, and human harmony; second, Yuejun. Keeping obligations are common for all of society, no one exception. June envoys to ceremony. Good morning, you never dared to disrespect the people. (The Analects · zilu) good morning ceremony, is easy to make (the Analects · asked), thirdly, to party. In order to save the world, he made a ceremony for the country (the Analects · advanced) political and legal advocates. He hoped that the nobility at all levels can use etiquette and humility to govern the country, considers as a land of propriety and compliance (the Analects · LY Nhan), social problems will be a good solution.
(B) German.
German words meaning both moral, conduct, there are also undok, meaning grace. Moral adjustment inner, purification of the mind. Confucius believed that Sage gentleman of monarchs should be of high moral character, is the embodiment of moral perfection. Zun five us, holding four evil (the Analects · Yao Yue). Confucius believed that politics to morality, such as the North Star, it stars arch (the Analects · politics), preach my benevolence, siren to (the Analects · in), gentleman’s accomplishment of the training, in particular those in power, emphasizing the moral basis of law. For the common people, and Confucius advocated by virtue of the road, aligned with ceremony, road to Government, aligned with punishment, people from shameless; there is shame and (the Analects · politics). He believes that, with the penalty to dispose of people, people only from the heart of the penalty, and no sense of shame, and ethics to guide the people, people will not only be contrary to the moral stigma of heart, and would willingly comply with social norms. Confucius also says wind gentleman’s virtue, Curs de grass, grass of the wind, will fall on one ‘ s back. [Papers in the world] (the Analects · Yan Yuan), which means ruler’s moral like the wind, people’s moral like grass. Rulers advocated moral, governance will be as smooth as a straw in the wind. In short, the source of Confucian philosophy of law, it was his moral philosophy, good laws are derived from good virtue, is respect for people; draconian laws derived from the evil German, is contempt for people; that is, and, without exception, and even Kant said that the ultimate purpose is the Mission of all of mankind, and this mission is the philosophy of moral science. To moral philosophy for all the other rational pursuit of superior status, we have since ancient times has been both understood as philosopher of this name, and first of all, understood as a moral science. [4] the importance of the rule of law is that it is the moral law applies with the necessary means of implementation and fundamental guarantee, is a regulation by virtue of its purpose, is social harmony.
(C) punishment.
In General, the law established on the evil of presets, is passive, preventive and punitive; morality based on good presets that are proactive, self-discipline and improve. Of say of good and evil is prevention, and in real life, perfecting and do of the evil men who exist, but are very rare, Wanli hard to pick one. The vast majority of people are intersecting mix of good and evil, but the proportion is different, you increase the complexity of human approach, but this position, shows that majority of plasticity, indicates that the necessity of the moral and legal punishment. If we on humanity estimated too low, awareness not to people most can through education reached has shame and grid, and negative Dehua of necessity, that is on humanity of errors read; but if we towards another extreme, on humanity estimated too high, thought all of people are can through education and reached has shame and grid and negative align of to criminal, people from and shameless of rule of law necessity, also is on humanity of errors read. In the view of Confucius, who is not a simple congenital problems of good and evil, but similar, XI Xiang Yuan (the Analects · Yang goods) shaping the day after tomorrow, and thus create a human existence through Dehua, the rule of law, good environment for the growth is vital. He very seriously, punishment for Germany, maintains an appropriate level of tension between the two, and should not have too many things to take care of at the same time. He said: the good and the Ephesians! Political kuanzemin slow, slow correction with Meng. Slam the residual, residual effects in wide. Width to JI Meng, Meng jikuan, politics is based on and. (The RAR · zhaogong 20 years) in Confucius’s view, only the complementary Dehua, the rule of law, to good situation, national dazhi. Confucius to g by courtesy, as a means of punishment of Germany, has been cultivating moral character. Reached its purpose then align, alignment and governance, governance and the world (the rites · universities), the ultimate goal is to achieve social harmony in the world.
Four, harmony of purpose.
As the originator of Confucianism of Confucius, is its central task of ideological and moral character, family, country, flat world. Its aim is to hit the world thought of harmonious Datong ideal law, in the rites of the Confucian classics in one of the five classics · ritual games article full of vivid description, modern pioneer of Chinese revolutionary Sun Yat-Sen’s ideal and ideological origin is derived from this of all under heaven are equal. That vision has inspired countless people with lofty ideals for thousands of years to explore and to struggle constantly. Confucian ideal of harmonious society is presented by: carers, friends, small arms. Until today, we view this three point are is great of ideal, in today world range within also no which national can to this three who do was comparison satisfaction, may in today of people seems, this a ideal too not reality, and too pedantic has, Confucian thought also often was people criticism too high-sounding and impracticable, Confucius I on was sarcasm for know its not and for of, as panic-stricken homeless dog. But this is what Confucius honored as a Saint by later generations of noble, later Confucius Sage of Zhang Zai’s heaven and Earth in the song State heart, living people erecting one’s fate, as a secondary juexue Saint, for Jesus Christ opened Pacific is also ideal for flush direct inheritance of university governance and become a long spiritual pillar of the Chinese nation. Law, legal culture and the modern legal thought and legal culture has some amazing agree without prior consultation, thought of Confucian ethics law is also included on the rational enlightenment thought by many modern systems. Accumulation of legal concept it has deep in our consciousness. One can Hong Road, Hong-man non-road. An in-depth study on it, help us with our traditional legal culture of ethnic insight.
References:
[1] [De] Kant. Principles of moral metaphysics [m]. Fan Litian translation. Shanghai: Shanghai people’s publishing house, 1986:80.
[2] the Chinese Department of Peking University. Xun Zixin note [m]. Beijing: Peking University Press, 1979:500.
[3] Zhou Zhenfu. Zhou Yi photograph [m]. Beijing: zhonghuashuju, 1991:172.
[4] [De] Kant. The critique of pure reason [m]. Deng Xiaomang, translation. Beijing: people’s publishing house, 2000:634.

论和谐是孔子法哲学的范式
摘要:孔子的法哲学范式是和谐,“仁”是其范式的基石,民与君、个人、家庭及国家的和谐是该范式的内容,礼、德和刑是和谐的手段,而建构和谐的目的是大同世界。
关键词:孔子;和谐;法哲学。
孔子的政治哲学思想向来为人们所重视,只是这种重视不够全面的,过分倚重其德治思想,对其法哲学思想则过于忽视了。孔子强调德治作为软手段,并没有忽视法治这一强硬的手段,法治作为铁的手段是绝对不可或缺的,但是如果只强调法治这一手段,抛弃法治里的道德基础,就蕴含着极大的理论危险性,最终导致治国的失败。这是为历史所证明,显示了孔子在这个问题上的非凡洞察力和先见之明。孔子无论德治也好,还是法治也好,其中的最终目的就是达到和谐,可以这样讲,和谐就是孔子法哲学的范式,正如三权分立的鼻祖孟德斯鸠所言我们应当用法律去阐明历史,用历史去阐明法律。这同历史法学派萨维尼所指出的那样,法是世代相传的民族精神或民族意识的体现,他还指出,不仅法律产生于民族精神和民族意识,法律的发展同样也不能脱离民族精神和民族意识。从中华法系中可以看出,儒家思想或称儒家意识已经深深在我们的民族中打下烙印,无论从过去的法律,还是从现在的法律,或多或少的找到儒家的影子。中国传统法哲学是以儒家法哲学思想为主干和正统,而儒家法哲学的基本特征就是伦理法,即以伦理关系来涵析法律关系,以道德准则来统帅和引导法律,以伦理价值为法的价值,所以是以伦理道德为法的本原、本体和价值取向的法哲学。而这种伦理道德既是一种观念和理念,也可以外化为实体和器物,既包括个人、家庭、群体和国家伦理。其内涵在治国原则、政治制度和国家结构中。而孔子作为儒家的开山鼻祖,其和谐作为法哲学的范式当然可视为中华民族法律意识或法律精神。
一、和谐的基石。
孔子的整个法哲学的目的是和谐,而仁是他的法哲学本体论的基本出发点。它的基本意义,就如黑格尔的绝对观念与其法哲学体系的关系。不过黑格尔的绝对观念乃是超时空的抽象体,而孔子的仁却是有突出人的主观自觉精神的深刻意味,乃是人实践理性的升华。孔子继承远古民族社会的民主遗风,并抽象化为仁学原则,确立了以个人血缘宗族伦理为本位的法哲学人学本体观。这一法哲学本体观所要建立的,正是对法律现象世界中主体地位的清醒把握,并且反映了中国法制历史从野蛮走向和谐文明的发展过程,反映了人的价值逐渐被重视,人的地位逐渐提高的历史事实。它从一个侧面对中国古代社会法制非人主义,提出了理性的诘难。孔子的仁学本体论内容:首先是界定何谓仁?在研究孔子思想最可靠的著作,也是儒家的经典!
《论语》中,讲仁达109次之多。仁者,爱人可以看作是孔子对仁的总要概括,樊迟问仁。子曰爱人(《论语·颜渊》)。爱人就是同情、关心、爱护他人的真实情感。这些情感具体体现为孝、悌、忠、信、恭、宽、敏、慧、温、良、俭、让、忠恕等各种善行和美德。可见,仁是各种美德的总和,是人生追求的最高境界。成为仁者,实在不易。所以,孔子从不轻易以仁者许人,也不以仁者自许。
由于爱人是对他人爱护的真实情感的流露,因此,这一思想体现了对人的重视和关心。据载:厩焚,子退朝,曰:‘伤人乎’?不问马。(《论语·乡党》)马棚失火,孔子关心的是人有没有伤着。孔子还对奴隶制的不人道甚为反感,用始作俑者,其无后乎(《孟子·梁惠王上》),恶毒咒骂用土俑、木俑殉葬的人。对土俑、木俑殉葬,都如此痛恨,可以想象他对人殉的态度了。孔子的爱人思想还体现出了对人的价值的深刻认识。他从现实社会出发,立足人间,注重人事,强调人的存在和对人的尊重,认为人类的事情只能由人类自身解决,从不寄希望于神鬼:子不语怪、力、乱、神。(《论语·述而》)子路问事鬼神,子曰:’未能事人,焉能事鬼‘。(《论语·雍也》)子路又问死,孔子说:未知生,焉知死。(《论语·雍也》)他还说:务民之义,敬鬼神而远之。(《论语·雍也》)孔子不是无神论者,并没有否定神鬼的存在。
但他对神鬼采取的是存而不论、敬而远之的态度,其目的就是重视人事,而不是鬼事。事实上孔子在强调人是目的,法和德只不过是手段而已。而道德和法律是源和流的关系,人之何以为人的目的和人之何以为人的手段的关系。人在孔子哲学里是大写的,天之所生,地之所养,以人为大,这和康德的主张是一致的!!!人任何时候都必须被当作目的。[1]孔子所说的听讼,吾犹人也,必也使无诉乎(《论语·颜渊》),表明他化解听讼而为无讼的法律方法和目标追求;法律惩恶只是手段而非目的,因而最理想的状态是人人能够遵守法度而免受其罚;法治的重要性决不意味着:刑重、法酷、案多、囚众,相反恶法在本质上和法治是对立的,真正的法治当建立善法上。唯仁者能好人,能恶人(《论语·里仁》);苟志于仁矣,无恶也(《论语·里仁》);季康子患盗问于孔子,孔子答曰:苟子之不欲,虽赏之不窃!
(《论语·颜渊》)一语中的(季康子)患盗在于(季康子)己贪;联系先富后教,不教而杀谓之虐的主张。一个民族的文化精神、道德理念、法律原则等合理内核是不变的,法律所体现的以仁为核心,以人为目的的正义原则是不可改变的。孔子的仁为基础宣扬要用社会发展、社会正义、礼让、教化等利民安邦措施来减少和预防犯罪的发生,从而构建和谐社会。
二、和谐的内容。
(一)民与君和谐。
在孔子的法哲学中首先要论证民与君之间的和谐,孔子深知民与君的关系。《荀子》一书中也记载了孔子把人民摆在基础地位的回答:且丘闻之,君者,舟也;庶人,水也,水则载舟,水则覆舟。[2]后世著名的水能载舟,也能覆舟这一警句即脱胎于此。事实上孔子要求构建和谐社会的法哲学思想,就要协调民与君的关系,而这种关系的协调的思想就是民本思想和相对的君主思想。
1.民本思想。
《论语》中记载:民之于仁也,甚于水火。这指出了老百姓盼望仁政比需求水火更迫切。所重:民、食、丧、祭。就是说在孔子心目中,人民居于首位,居第二位的食,实际上仍是重民的表现。第三、四点可用曾参的一句话概括:慎终追远,民德归厚矣。慎终就是办好父母的丧事,追远就是搞好祖先的祭祀,仍然是民本思想的体现。后来孟子的民为贵,社稷次之,君为轻的思想仍是这一思想的继承和发展,这一思想也使儒家思想当中最为精华之点。子贡问政。子曰:’足食。足兵。民信之矣。‘子贡曰:’必不得已而去,于斯三者何先?’曰:‘去兵。’子贡曰:’必不得已而去,于斯二者何先?’曰:‘去食。自古皆有死,民无信不立。’(《论语·颜渊》)足食代表粮食充足,用现在的话来说,就是要搞好经济建设,足兵就是要加强国防建设;民信就是要取信于民。在孔子看来,死亡都不可怕,最可怕的是失掉民心,失掉民心的君主是无药可救的。可见自古皆有死,民无信不立的人本原则确实是千古不易的法则,也是儒家思想中处理好君民和谐最可宝贵的精神财富。
2.相对的君主思想。
孔子虽然主张民本主义,但绝不否定君主的主导地位,只不过是相对的君主主义。天下有道,则礼乐征伐自天子出;天下无道,则礼乐征伐自诸侯出。自诸侯出,盖十世希不失矣;自大夫出,五世希不失矣;陪臣执国命,三世希不失矣。天下有道,则政不在大夫。天下有道,则庶人不议。(《论语·季氏》)这里的天下无道是指社会生活的一切政治法律秩序被打破了,中央政府对地方势力控制不了,没有办法贯彻命令,形成了地方的割据专权,国家的统一受到威胁。孔子是主张国家的统一,而且统一于一个君主之下。事实上这一论断就是指孔子主张君主专制主义,反对民主政治,但是,按照孔子的要求,要成为一名合格的君主简直近乎完美,这是非常困难的。予小子履,敢用玄牡,敢昭告于皇皇后帝;有罪不敢赦。帝臣不蔽,简在帝心。朕躬有罪,无以万方,万方有罪,罪在朕躬。周有大赍,善人是富,虽有周亲,不如仁人。
百姓有过,在予一人。(《论语·尧曰》)由此可见孔子主张的君主专制是建立在民本基础上,君主必须代表人民的利益,不然就是不合格的君主,就不能同人民进行和谐相处,人民就要起来推翻他,这种思想就是革命的思想,《易经》中指出:天地革命而四时成。汤武革命,顺乎天而应乎人。[3]善人为邦百年,亦可以胜残去杀矣(《论语·子路》);子谓《韶》:尽美矣,又尽善也;谓《武》:尽美关,未尽善也。(《论语·八佾》)应该说孔子对汤武革命是充分肯定的,但其毕竟是通过战争夺取,与虞舜的尽善尽美的殚让相比,虽尽美而未尽善,这句话表明了孔子法哲学的目标取向。后来孟子就极力赞扬汤武革命。孔子主张君主主义在一定程度上是承认君、臣、民之间是相对平等的,在权利和义务上也是和谐的,而不是偏倚一面的,不同于后世封建专制发展到极端的君要臣死,臣不得不死的君主主义拥有对臣、民绝对权利的那种极不和谐的范式。
(二)个人、家庭、国家的和谐。
孔子在其《论语》中还阐述了其个人、家庭、国家的和谐的法哲学思想,将其个人至于家庭、社会和国家三个团体之中。
第一,在家庭中,人与人的和谐关系形式主要是父慈子孝。子女对父母要尽孝道。父母在世时,子女应当留家侍奉:子曰:父母在,不远游,游必有方。(《论语·里仁》)侍奉父母,要竭尽全力:事父母,能竭其力。(《论语·学而》)对父母尽孝,不能只养,还应敬。孔子说:今之孝者,是谓能养,至于犬马,皆能有养,不敬,何以别乎?(《论语·为政》)光养不敬,与养犬马就没区别了。因此,应生,事之以礼;死,葬之以礼,祭之以礼(《论语·为政》)。在父母子女关系上,孔子并没有单方面要求子女尽义务,他对父母也提出义务要求!!!慈。曰:孟武伯问孝。子曰:父母唯其(子)疾之忧。这句话虽然讲的还是为孝的理由,但从另一个方面说明,父母应爱其子并无所不至,唯恐其子有疾病而常以为忧。孔子所说的父父、子子就是父要尽父的义务,就是子要尽子的义务,并且父像个父的样子,慈爱关怀子女,才能理直气壮的要求子孝。另外,孔子认为子女对父母尽孝应是从内心真诚地敬事父母,不是不辨不非,盲从父母的愚孝。盲从父母,不算孝。慈和孝是爱的不同形式,因此,父母子女间是互爱的关系形式,他们之间的权利义务是相互的。后世封建法典的父为子纲原则,把一切权力归于父母,维护绝对的父权,子女只有义务,没有权利,显然是对孔子思想的修正。然而,孝悌也者,其为人之本与(《论语·学而》),孝悌,即孝敬父母,尊敬长辈,是仁的根本。这说明在协调家庭中父母子女间的权利义务关系上,价值倾向于父权。
第二,在国家中,人与人的和谐关系形式主要是君使臣以礼,臣事君以忠(《论语·八佾》)。国家实际上是家族的放大。君相当于父,臣民相当于子孙。故而,孔子移孝至忠,要求臣对君要忠,民对君要顺。他对春秋时代颠倒尊卑秩序,无视君主的现实大加鞭伐,天下有道,则礼乐征伐自天子出;天下无道,则礼乐征伐自诸侯出(《论语·季氏》)。[天下论文]把君主地位不保,政权下移的情况,斥之为天下无道。他极力鼓吹正名,确定君君、臣臣的等级名分,并将其看作是治民理国的首要任务:名不正则言不顺,言不顺则事不成,事不成则礼乐不兴,礼乐不兴则刑罚不中,刑罚不中则民无所措手足。(《论语·子路》)为了维护君主的地位,要求臣对君要尽心竭力,忠心耿耿:事君,能致其身。(《论语·学而》)事君尽礼。(《论语·八佾》臣事君以忠。但孔子也对君提出了要求。君主要以礼待臣,尽其君道。君使臣以礼,臣事君以忠就说明了君主只有以礼待臣,臣方能以忠事君。所以他反对臣下行不辨善恶、盲从君主的愚忠。臣下对君主不要曲意逢迎,要敢于直谏:勿欺也,而犯之。(《论语·宪问》)君主若护短拒谏,臣下宁肯离他而去:以道事君,不可则止。(《论语·宪问》)君主贤明,则做官;君主昏庸无道,去做官就可耻的:邦有道,谷,邦无道,谷,耻也。(《论语·宪问》)可见,君臣之间和谐的形式是互爱。虽然这种和谐侧重于君权,但对君权是有限制。后世的君为臣纲实际上是对孔子思想的修正。
第三,在社会中人与人之间的关系准则是己所不欲,勿施于人(《论语·卫灵公》)。宗族和国家群体中的人与人的关系主要是基于血缘、政治而形成的特定身份关系。除了这些特定的身份关系,便是基于共同的社会属性而形成的人与人的关系。社会群体中人与人的关系具有普遍性,而宗族和国家群体中人与人的关系具有特殊性。那么,孔子是怎样建构这种普遍意义的人与人的关系呢?他说:夫仁者,已欲立而立人,已欲达而达人。能取近譬,可谓仁之方也。(《论语·卫灵公》)自己想站立,也要使别人站立;想满足自己的要求,也要使别人的要求得到满足,这样与人相处就和谐。方法就是能取近譬,即设身处地,将心比心,推已及人地为别人着想。这种与人相处和谐的方法,孔子也称它为忠。这是积极地与人和谐相处的方法。孔子还说:己所不欲,勿施于人。就是自己不喜欢的事,也不要强加给别人。这样与人和谐,孔子叫它恕。它比起己欲立而立人,己欲达而达人的忠来说,较为消极地与人和谐相处的方法,但较为容易做到。故当子贡问孔子:有一言而可以终身行之者乎?(《论语·卫灵公》)孔子问答:其恕乎!己所不欲,勿施于人。(《论语·卫灵公》)孔子将忠恕看作是贯穿他自己思想体系的人与人关心的根本准则。所谓夫子之道,忠恕而己矣(《论语·里仁》)。忠恕之道充分体现了人与人之间的相互理解和彼此尊重。相比君臣、父子之间更具平等性,也更能相和谐。
三、和谐的手段。
孔子在构建和谐的社会,主要采用下列三种方法:礼、德、刑。
(一)礼。
礼是西周以来形成的一整套典章制度,礼仪风俗,基本内容是以血缘为纽带,以君君、臣臣、父父、子子为核心的宗法等级制度。第一方面,以礼约己。孔子说:克己复礼为仁。(《论语·颜渊》)可见,复礼是克己的手段。所谓:非礼勿视,非礼勿听,非礼勿言,非礼勿动。(《论语·颜渊》)如果能以礼约束自己,就可做到无所过失,行为永不偏误:君子博学于文,约之以礼,矣可以弗畔矣夫。(《论语·里仁》)用礼约束自己,自然就会形成知分守分的性格,为人处世自会小心谨慎,这样就不会出乱子,就能与人和谐;第二方面,以礼约君。守礼是社会所有人的共同义务,任何人都不例外。君使臣以礼。上好礼,则民莫敢不敬。(《论语·子路》)上好礼,则民易使也(《论语·宪问》);第三方面,以礼约国。为了救世,他提出了为国以礼(《论语·先进》)的政治法律主张。他希望各级贵族能用礼制和谦让来治理国家,认为能以礼让为国(《论语·里仁》),各种社会问题就会得到很好的解决。
(二)德。
德字既有道德、品行含义,有又恩德、恩惠的含义。道德是规正内心,净化心灵。孔子认为,君主应是品德高尚的贤人君子,是道德完美的化身。应尊五美,屏四恶(《论语·尧曰》)。孔子认为为政以德,譬如北辰,居其所而众星拱之(《论语·为政》),宣扬我欲仁,斯仁至矣(《论语·述而》),培养人特别是当权者的君子之修养,强调法的道德的基础。对于老百姓而言,孔子主张道之以德,齐之以礼,道之以政,齐之以刑,民免而无耻;有耻且格(《论语·为政》)。他认为,用刑罚去处置民众,民众只有免受处罚之心,而没有耻辱的感觉,而用道德去引导民众,民众不仅会有违背道德的耻辱之心,而且会自觉地遵守社会规范。孔子还认为:君子之德风,小人之德草,草上之风,必偃。[天下论文](《论语·颜渊》)也就是说统治者的道德像风,老百姓的道德像草。提倡统治者的道德,治理国家就会像风吹草倒一样顺利。总之,孔子的法哲学的源泉,那就是他的道德哲学,善法源自善德,就是对人的尊重;恶法源自恶德,就是对人的蔑视;这一点,古今中外,概莫能外,以至康德说终极目的无非是人类的全部使命,而有关这种使命的哲学就是道德学。为了道德哲学对于一切其他理性追求的优越地位之故,我们自古以来也一直把哲学家这个名称同时理解为,并且首先理解为道德学家。[4]法治的重要性在于它是道德律适用与实现的必要手段和根本保证,德治其目的就是一种调控,是社会趋于和谐。
(三)刑。
一般来讲,法律建立在性恶预设上,是被动的、预防性和惩戒性的;道德建立在性善预设上,是主动的、自律的和提升性的。之所以说性善、性恶是预防,在与现实生活中,完善和尽恶之人尽管是存在的,但都是极少数的,万里难挑其一。绝大多数之人是善恶相交混的,但比例是不同的,则就增加了人性探讨的复杂性;但这个定位,表明大多数人的可塑性,表明道德教化和法律惩戒的必要性。如果我们对人性估计太低,认识不到人大部分能够通过教化达到有耻且格,而否定德化的必要性,那就是对人性的误读;但如果我们走向另一个极端,对人性估计太高,以为所有的人都能够通过教化而达到有耻且格而否定齐之以刑,民免而无耻的法治必要性,同样是对人性的误读。在孔子看来,人能性并非简单的先天性的善恶问题,而是性相近也,习相远也(《论语·阳货》)的后天塑造,因而通过德化、法治营造人的生存,成长的良好环境是至关重要的。他对于德、刑都是很重视的,二者之间保持着适当的张力,而不可顾此失彼。他说:善哉!政宽则民慢,慢则纠之以猛。猛则民残,残则施之以宽。宽以济猛,猛以济宽,政是以和。(《左传·昭公二十年》)在孔子看来,只有德化、法治的互补,才能政通人和、国家大治。孔子通过礼、德、刑作为手段来克已修身。其目的达到身修而后家齐,家齐而后国治,国治而后天下平(《礼记·大学》),最终目的是平天下即达到社会和谐。
四、和谐的目的。
孔子作为儒家的鼻祖,其思想的中心任务是修身、齐家、治国、平天下。其目的就是要创下天下和谐的大同理想法思想,在儒家经典五经之一的《礼记·礼运》篇中有完整生动的阐述,近代中国革命的先行者孙中山先生的天下为公的理想的思想渊源来源于此。这一理想千百年来也一直激励着无数的志士仁人不断地去探索、去奋斗。孔子所提出的和谐理想社会是:老者安之,朋友信之,少者怀之。直到今天,我们来看这三点都是了不起的理想,在当今世界范围内也没有哪个国家能把这三者做得比较满意,也许在当今的人看来,这一理想太不现实、太迂腐了,儒家思想也经常被人批评过于迂阔,孔子本人就被讥讽为知其不可而为之,如丧家之犬。但是这正是孔子被后世尊为圣人崇高之处,后世宋代大儒张载所提出的为天地立心,为生民立命,为往圣继绝学,为万世开太平的也是直接承继大学的修齐平治的理想并成为中华民族长期以来精神支柱。法律思想、法律文化与现代法律思想、法律文化有着某些惊人的暗合,儒家伦理法思想也包含着对现代系统法思想的很多合理启示。它的法律观念已深深的积淀于我们的意识中。人能弘道,非道弘人。对它进行深入研究,有助于我们对自己传统法律文化民族性的深刻认识。
参考文献:
[1][德]康德。道德形而上学原理[M].范力田,译。上海:上海人民出版社,1986:80.
[2]北京大学中文系。荀子新注[M].北京:北京大学出版社,1979:500.
[3]周振甫。周易译注[M].北京:中华书局,1991:172.
[4][德]康德。纯粹理性批判[M].邓晓芒,译。北京:人民出版社,2000:634.
It would be very appreciated, if enthusiasts can provide with a better trаnslаtiоn.